| Name | Pos | Salary | Through | Years Left | Notes | Years in Majors |
| R. Bresnahan | CF | $16,130,000 | 1912 | 4 years left | | 12 years |
| R. Waddell | SP | $6,500,000 | 1912 | 4 years left | | 13 years |
| W. Conroy | SS | $5,540,000 | 1911 | 3 years left | | 7 years |
| C. Lundgren | MR | $3,514,286 | 1909 | 1 years left | Free agent after this season! | 6 years |
| L. Houtz | CF | $3,500,000 | 1910 | 2 years left | | 8 years |
| F. West | MR | $3,000,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Free agent after this season! | 9 years |
| B. Friel | CF | $2,950,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Extension signed. | 6 years |
| C. Hickman | 1B | $2,850,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Arbitration (Estimate: $1,960,000), could become Free Agent with 45 more days of service this year. | 5 years |
| A. Devlin | 3B | $2,685,714 | 1909 | 1 years left | Arbitration (Estimate: $1,620,000), could become Free Agent with 108 more days of service this year. | 5 years |
| O. Overall | SP | $2,600,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Arbitration (Estimate: $760,000) | 4 years |
| H. Howell | MR | $1,100,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Extension signed. | 8 years |
| J. Taylor | MR | $640,000 | 1910 | 2 years left | | 11 years |
| C. Case | SP | $441,429 | 1909 | 1 years left | Extension signed. | 6 years |
| J. Pastorius | MR | $331,429 | 1909 | 1 years left | Arbitration (Estimate: $390,000) | 3 years |
| F. Roth | C | $300,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Free agent after this season! | 6 years |
| M. Mitchell | RF | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Possible Arbitration, 125 more days of service needed this year. | 2 years |
| H. Ferris | 2B | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Possible Arbitration, 94 more days of service needed this year. | 2 years |
| G. Moriarty | 2B | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 1 years |
| T. Pruiett | SP | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 0 years |
| B. Louden | 3B | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 0 years |
| B. Bescher | LF | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 0 years |
| B. Abstein | 2B | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 0 years |
| T. Tuckey | SP | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 1 years |
| J. Archer | C | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 0 years |
| C. Wilson | LF | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 1 years |
| W. Mitchell | SP | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 1 years |
| I. Thomas | C | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Arbitration (Estimate: $2,180,000) | 3 years |
| N. Rucker | SP | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Possible Arbitration, 172 more days of service needed this year. | 2 years |
| R. Murray | LF | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Arbitration (Estimate: $1,220,000) | 3 years |
| R. Oldring | 2B | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Arbitration (Estimate: $2,640,000) | 3 years |
| W. Clement | RF | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Automatic Resign. | 0 years |
| W. Alperman | SS | $250,000 | 1909 | 1 years left | Possible Arbitration, 45 more days of service needed this year. | 2 years |
| H. Curtis | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| S. Shannon | LF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| F. Gaiser | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| A. Fletcher | SS | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| F. Smith | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| F. Burns | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Knotts | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Graney | 1B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| O. Baldwin | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| C. Elliott | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Bernard | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| T. Latimer | LF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| E. Lafitte | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Ohl | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| T. Raftery | RF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| B. Reilly | 2B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Quinn | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| A. Bader | LF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| J. Mullin | 2B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| H. Cassady | RF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | Minor League FA next year! | 0 years |
| R. Ellam | SS | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| S. Kelly | 3B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| N. Kahl | 2B | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| W. Justis | MR | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| H. Davidson | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| T. Neuer | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| R. Downey | RF | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Donovan | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| J. Byrnes | C | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
| B. Forman | SP | Minor-League-Contract | - | - | | 0 years |
|